Differences between contracts of donation and purchase and sale. What is better and more profitable: sell or give land plot? Pros and disadvantages

Civil Code, paragraph 2 of Art. 167 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation).

There is a certain degree of challengility of the transaction in court, in particular, when the donor actors the elderly, or a gifted face is unfair.
The donor does not get anything in response to donation, since such a deal is one-sided binding.
The donator cannot put any burdens on the property that gives, since a believer, becoming his owner, has the right to dispose of them at its own discretion.
Payment of income tax individuals (NDFL) for those who are not a relative of the donor.

Autobravo: What is profitable, gift or sale contract?

Duration of ownership by car.

How best to re-refline the car: a gift or sale contract?

The contract must have the following data:

information about the city in which the deal was concluded;
passport details;
car model, year of manufacture, color, engine number sign;
what you pass with the machine (documents, winter tires and so on).

Documents for car reissue:

contract (3 copies);
statement;
passports;
document on car registration;
insurance;
driver's license;
act of acceptance and transmission;
a document that establishes the absence of encumbrances;
the consent of the spouse if the car is joint property;
receipt of payment of state duty.

We learn how to re-inform the car on a relative, without removing it from her.

What is better to make a gift or buy-selling on the car?

They will be transferred to the instance for state registration. You also need to have another original that will become a guide document.

If the donation contract was wound at the notary, it is necessary to provide originals by the number of executives of the transaction plus one copy of this contract.
Issue from technical passport from BTI.
After collecting documents, it must be transferred to Rosreestr to register the transfer of ownership.
If real estate is transferred by means of a gift to the person under 14, then permission from parents or guardians, which confirms that it is allowed to take property.

Dear or sale contract - What is better?

Rights and obligations of the parties The list of a wide list is narrow (the donor - obliged to transfer the gift, has the right to cancel the donation, the refusal to execute the contract of donation; a gifted person - has the right to accept the object of donation, in the promise of donation - to require its transfer to the adoption of imposing conditions) For non-performance or improper performance of duties under the contract, there is a place (as a rule, in the form of contest, penalties, penalties, interest for the use of other people's money) There is no compulsory conditions for the absence / availability of encumbrances, restrictions, arrest; information about persons who retain the right to use residential premises or on the absence of those (art.
This transaction is easier to commit between relatives.

If the location of the owner cannot be determined, it should be applied to the tax, indicating that the car was sold by proxy. Also in the statement ask to be considered a tax payer of the new car owner. If a failure comes, it is possible to appeal in court.
Get rid of the duties of payment of fines and taxes on the car already sold, you can try using the filing in the traffic police statement about the disposal of the vehicle.
The question can be resolved positively. When the car is taken from accounting due to recycling, penalties and taxes will cease to be accrued. It is only necessary to notify the tax on the date of write-off and scouring the machine.

How best to re-transfer the car on a relative?

However, when selling a share in the property, it is necessary to take into account the presence of the preemptive right of interest rates. But, if there is a donation, the co-owners are not the right to prepare. This is the circumstance of what the donation differs from buying and selling, you need to keep in mind before making a deal.

Pros and disadvantages of transactions most objectively demonstrates that better donation or purchase and sale of an apartment, detailed analysis each of the types of agreements. The advantages of domestic positive arguments will be:

Ease of design. It is enough to make an agreement and register in the registry.
The notarial form is not required if the transaction is carried out between adults and capable entities.
The ability to avoid paying tax. For this it is necessary that the parties appealed close relatives.

What is the cheaper contract of donation or sale of the car

Although at the same time this fact acts a plus for the receiving a gift.

Recognition of the contract of donation is insignificant if the conditions and requirements for registration are violated. The most common option is a preliminary deal.

Ease of imprisonment.
It is permissible to conclude an agreement in oral and simple writing. In some cases, a notary form will be required.
There are no special limitations in part of the subjects of the transaction. Of course, it is necessary to take into account the limitations of Art. 171-172 of the Civil Code.
Obtaining profit for the transfer of property is a compensated nature of the transaction.

Choosing that it is better to make a gift or buying a car, an apartment or a land plot at all, it is necessary to understand that the substitution of one contract by others leads to insignificance of the agreement, as this is regarded as a feigned deal. A context will be recognized as an agreement decorated in order to disguise (hide) a different type of agreement. The negligible transaction leads to a "rollback" of conditions at the time of signing, and may also have additional legal consequences.
Planning to sell an apartment, that is, to make a profit from the transfer of real estate to another person, it is necessary to issue a contract of sale, and if the transfer does not imply benefits, it is necessary to issue a gift. If it is necessary to make a choice, which is better than the gift or purchase and sale of the apartment, then this is an agreement that reflects the validity of the procedure for transferring property.

Legal assistance!

moscow and region.

st. Petersburg and region.

Federal number

zOOMINGFOTO1712 / FOTOLIA

The advisers of the Seda Toplakaltqian (

The main difference of the contract of donation from the purchase and sale of real estate is his gloom. In the case of transmission under the contract of the donation of the counter-side, the contract is a preliminary deal, that is, insignificant.

Advantages of the contract of donation:

No duty to pay for personal income tax (Further NDFL) in the event of a contract between close relatives (paragraphs 18.1 of paragraph 18 of Article 217 of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation). These are parents and children, grandfather, grandmother and grandchildren, brothers and sisters.
Confired waiting time for subsequent alienation under the sale contract. With the subsequent sale of real estate adopted as a gift, NDFL does not need to pay after three years (paragraph 3 of Article 217.1 of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation). And in the contract of sale - in five years.
At the conclusion of the Darment Agreement, the property of real estate is not required to comply with the rule on the preemptive right of purchase by other co-owners. And when concluding a purchase and sale agreement, the rest of the participants dolly ownership have the preferential right to buy a share (article 250 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation).
The donation agreement can be terminated by the donor in a certain law. So, if the gifted committee made an attempt on the life of a donor, the life of some of the members of his family or close relatives either deliberately caused bodily injuries to the donor, he was entitled to cancel the donation (Article 578 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation).
The real estate transferred under the contract of donation during the period of marriage is not covered by the regime of the overall joint ownership of spouses. Real estate is the sole property of a spouse who received her as a gift (Article 36 of the RF IC).

The main disadvantages of the contract of donation:

When concluding a contract of donation between third parties, it is necessary to pay NDFL In the amount of 13% of the value of the property taken as a gift.
Dear agreement is easier to challenge in court And recognize invalid.
It is prohibited to donation in relations between commercial organizations (PP. 4 p. 1 of Article 575 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation).
The valuation of property in total joint ownership is allowed only after receiving the consent of all co-owners (Article 576 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation).
The ability to cancel the contract of donation (minus for believed) (Article 578 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation).

Advantages of the contract of sale:

The seller is freed from payment of NDFLif the property is owned at least five years (For objects that were purchased from January 1, 2016 (clause 4 of Article 217.1 of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation).
Real estate sales contract contains less conditions for cancellation of the transaction from third parties.
Parties to the transaction can be both individuals and legal entities.

Disadvantages of purchase and sale agreement:

Long period of waiting for subsequent sale without personal income tax five years.
For real estate acquired under the contract of sale in the period of marriage, the regime of general joint ownership is distributed.
PRESENTAL RIGHT OF PURCHASE in other co-owners when selling the share of real estate object (Article 250 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation). In particular, when selling, it is necessary to notify the co-owners in writing about the intention of selling their share, as well as the co-owners have the right to take advantage of the price proposed by a third party.

Thus, in each individual case, with the alienation of real estate under the contract or purchase and sale agreement, it is necessary to take into account a number of circumstances, for example, the presence of a related communication, the period of service, the basis of the acquisition, and so on.

Experts of online techniques for the sale of apartments "Apartment-Uraz-Agent.Ru" are responsible:

The benefit is tensile. Under different purposes, the benefit is different. You can understand the convenience and legal consequences of the transaction for the current owner of the apartment or for the future (they will have different "benefits"). Dear agreement, like a purchase and sale agreement, a bilateral transaction. And what is beneficial to one may not be beneficial to another.

The goal determines benefits. For example, the goal may be concealing income from the sale of an apartment by replacing it to the contract of donation. Accordingly, the "benefit" here will be evaluated from this position. The goal may be the design of the deposit of the apartment (in the form of a donation or sale) when issuing a relatives for her to the saline to the saline. The goal may be investing in real estate and receiving tax preferences.

But we will risk assumed that it is only about taxes. That is, the question comes down to the fact that the type of transaction of the gift or purchase and sale will have to pay less taxes and the other side of the transaction. This can already be answered quite definitely.

In the case of the adoption of the apartment near the relative, any tax consequences in both sides of the transaction arises. But if the apartment gives an extraneous person, then the gifted income taxes: minus 13% of the cost of the apartment, since, from the point of view of taxes, he received a solid income and must pay for this tax to the state. The donator at the same time, naturally, should not be in the budget, as no income gets. By the way, the concept of the "close relative" of the law refers the following members of the donor family: spouses, children (including adopted), parents, grandparents, grandchildren, brothers and sisters (including consolidated).

In the case of the sale of the apartment, the situation is reverse. The seller receives income receives, and must pay the same 13% of the tax of personal income tax from it. True, the state provides a whole number of benefits for the payment of personal income tax in the form of tax deductions here.

The amount of tax deduction for the seller depends on how much time he owned the apartment and how this apartment fell to him to his property. For example, if the apartment was owned by the owner for more than three years (or was bought more than five years ago, according to the new rules), then when it, tax for the seller will be zero.

In other cases, the seller can reduce the taxable base that occurs only by 1 million rubles ( tax deduction). From the remaining amount, he is obliged to pay NDFL 13%.

The buyer in the case of purchase and sale, naturally, does not pay tax. And even on the contrary, it is possible to partially regain the NDFL, which he pays to the budget from its current revenues (including from his salary).

So, you can summarize: if the transaction occurs between relatives, then for both sides more profitable apartment Give (if, of course, there is no purpose to take money from a relative). If the transaction occurs between foreign people, it is more profitable to sell the apartment by applying tax deductions to it.

S.A lawyers are responsible. Ricci Residential Real Estate:

It depends on whose benefit is talking. If you are the owner of the apartment, then from a material point of view, it is more profitable for you to make a gift, since in the case of sale you will have to pay income tax (13% of the amount specified in the sale contract). On the other hand, if the person is giving up is not your closest relative, the tax in the amount of 13% of the cost of the apartment will have to pay him. The only case in which the tax does not have to pay anyone, this is if you design a donation agreement on a close relative (the first degree of kinship).

In addition, the Darment Agreement has additional advantages. Giving the housing, you guarantee that it will remain in the sole ownership of the person with any development of the situation. When concluding a contract of sale, this situation is possible, for example, the situation when the apartment becomes his joint property with his spouse (or his wife), and then, in the event of a divorce, it will have to share it as shared property.

If you give an apartment, then if you wish, you can stay in it (if you specify this condition in the Darment Treaty). And when making a real estate purchase and sale agreement, you can lose the right to accommodate if a new owner wants to sell it again (if you are not a person who has the right to continuous use privatized apartment And do not discharge from it at your own request). And, in general, the procedure for registration of the decoration is simpler than the procedure for issuing a sales contract.

Lawyer Sergey Mirzoyan answers:

This is a common question for legal advice. These contracts have a different purpose, and one contract is not worth covering others. In principle, such treaties are called pretend.

In the case of a purchase and sale contract, covered with donation, and in the case of a donation agreement, covered purchase and purchase, may come unfavorable to the parties. For example: when making a donation, actually covering the contract of sale, according to which the cash seller was transferred, the buyer risks not get money From the seller when recognizing the transaction is invalid. At the same time, he will be obliged to return the purchased property to the seller. And another example: signing a contract of sale, under which the donation agreement lies, the unscrupulous donator may challenge the purchase and sale agreement as a preliminary deal and to prove that the cash is actually not transmitted and could not be transferred.

The head of the interregional housing program "Move to St. Petersburg" is responsible, General Director of Nikolay Lavrov Nikolay Lavrov:

Giving implies a free print of property rights. Purchase and sale is the transfer of right for a certain amount of money. If the donation is carried out between close relatives, there is no tax on donation. If a stranger, the tax on donation will be 13% or from cadastral value Real estate or from the amount specified in the Darment Treaty (depending on what amount will be more).

The contract of sale is characterized by the fact that the seller and the buyer can put any arrangement of their amount. The cost of registration of the contract of sale (unless notaries) does not depend on the amount of the contract. If the object being sold is a shared property, the design of both transactions as donation and purchase and sale should be notarized. The cost of the notary services is calculated by the formula and depends on many factors. But, mostly, it is close to 0.5% of the cost of the apartment specified in the contract of donation or sale.

In case of deliberately understatement of the cost of the contract, the notary can calculate the cost of services depending on the estimated or cadastral value of the object. Thus, the cost of registration of contracts for donation and sale is about the same.

Different people may arise tax consequencesSince the gifted is taxed if there is no benefit. But the buyer of the apartment acquires tax breaking At income tax in the amount of 13% for the amount of purchase not exceeding 2 million rubles. That is, if the apartment is purchased for 2 million rubles and more, then its new owner will receive 260 thousand rubles from its paid income tax for several years.

The text has prepared Maria Gureeva

Sometimes, at the order of fate, various questions arise, the solution of which is entirely on us. It is necessary to be savvy to legally, to furnish any situation in good. There are situations when it is necessary to transform property (movable / real estate) to another person. There are two options - the contract of the gift of the property or its sale. The use of each has advantages, and at the same time presents risks. To deal with what kind of way it is better, it is necessary to consider the nuances of design and taxation. It is important for the presence of related links between the participants. So, you should figure out which method is more profitable, based on the specific situation.

This agreement, one side of which transfers the rights to its property, and the second takes them unconditionally, free and without any conditions.

Purchase and sale is an intention of the parties that owns the goods, sell it, and the buyer, for a certain amount of money to purchase this product.

But the difference between these operations is not only in the reimbursable essence of the transaction, namely in the presence of cash payments. To understand the positive and negative aspects of each agreement, we will analyze these documents in more detail in the article.

Why in the transaction transfer of property to another person sometimes used domestic? There are several positive moments In such a document. If the agreement is signed between the nearest relatives, gifted is not burdened with the tax on the received income, which is the market price of a presented object. These include relatives of the first line: parents, children, brothers and sisters. To register an act of transition, the rights of ownership will be needed to present a document that proves the relationship.

You can select several obvious advantages Darisan

Easy in design. The parties themselves can write a document without assistance.
The document can be made independently without the involvement of a specialist, it is not subject to compulsory assurance from the notary.
The ability to specify the timing of the transfer of the right to property, convenient for both the donor, and for being believed.
Ownership is only believed. After carrying out the entire process, the receiver receives full law For the use of presented property.
Exemption from paying tax (when the parties are connected by blood bonds).

Together with the benefits there are several minuses.

It is easier to recognize the invalidity of the Darment Agreement. Cancellation of domestic happens in judicial order. The legislation is spelled out that it is possible to cancel the action only if the donor is invisible (psychological or age disorders) or identified the fact of coercion of the signing of documents.
In the absence of close related links between the participants of the transaction, the tax is paid. The amount of tax is 13% of the estimated value, it is paid before submitting documents to Rosreestr. Also, if a relative decides to sell property before the expiration of the three-year period after a perfect purchase, it will be burdened with tax fee.
Denation does not provide for burdens or additional wishes. Gifiable has the right to dispose of donated as wishes after the registration act.

To register an act of transfer of rights to property, you need to prepare a set of documents:

passports of all participants in the agreement;
certificate of ownership;
filled with domestic blank;
extract from BTI;
in the event that the apparent not fulfilled 14 years, the consent of legal representatives (parents / guardians).

The procedure itself is carried out by notary or independently as parties with domestic. The procedure will undoubtedly delay if any errors will be detected during the check. If you do not want to mess around with papers yourself, it is necessary once to pay a professional who will make everything quickly and efficiently, will not miss anything and transfer all the data.

For the official entry into force of the contract, it is necessary to submit a set of documents to the Rosreestr of property rights. After the recipient begins to fully own property.

Purchase and sale agreement: All you need to know

The document is suitable for those who are afraid court proceedings Regarding the invalidity of domestic.

Important components of purchase and sale:

notarized husband's consent (wife) of the seller;
real estate received during the purchase is considered to be shared;
payment of duty in the amount of 13% of the price of sold ownership.

Mandatory details of the contract of sale include the data of the buyer and the seller, the estimated cost of real estate, the rights and obligations of each of the parties.

Regarding the purchase and purchase act, the following advantages can be attributed.

Compensated character. Receiving funds by the Seller is the basis for the inability to cancel its decision.
The ability to register in paper any conditions for both sides.
The possibility of obtaining a refund of overpaid income tax. Each citizen according to the law can take advantage of this right, in the amount of NDFL paid for them for the calendar year.
Simplicity and speed of design. The whole procedure will take about a month.
High reliability of the transaction. In court it is very difficult to challenge the contract, as it is an equal operation.
Exemption from tax from sale if the property was owned for more than three years.

The contract of sale has and undeniable minuses.

If the seller has property not more than 3 years, then he burden income tax From sale.
If the buyer is married, then the purchased property will be considered jointly acquired.

Perfect Real Estate Document: Dancher or sale contract?

Of the foregoing, when choosing a deal of sale and gift, the determining factor will be between what individuals the agreement is. If the parties come close to relatives, then it is better to make everything as a gift. Both sides will be able to get significant advantages, one of which, the procedure will cost almost free. If the owner wants to transfer his property to an unnecessary person, then it is better to make a purchase and sale. This method of transferring rights to property will save both sides of the transaction from a variety of risks and unpleasant situations. If still there are doubts, then it is necessary to consult with a specialist who will tell you how to do everything legally and at the same time most beneficial for the client.

Sometimes there are situations when the design of the gift seems to be the most profitable method for translating property rights. In the legislation, the transaction with intent of obtaining financial or legal benefits is described as a feigned or imaginary. Impact - carried out for the species, without consequences for the parties to the agreement. The pretended - lies with the calculation to cover the other. Both transactions are considered invalid by law. After canceling, everything is returned to the state that preceded before the conclusion of the contract. And in the end, the parties that the imaginary / pretended persuasion concluded will not receive the desired result.

The process of registration of the contract for the donation of residential real estate.

Domestic residential real estate is drawn up by the parties or notary at the location / registration of one of the participants. The process itself takes place in several stages:

Filling out the contract of donation. In addition to information about the participants, a distinguishing feature of a gift is described: Features Dara (Area, Floor), Real Estate Address, Share, Overgoing. All participants in the presence of a notary sign an agreement.

Payment of taxes. This item is intended only if the participants are not close relatives.

Registration of the contract. To register a degree of donation, you can contact the multifunctional center or Rosreestr of property rights. With you, you must have: filled out form, passports of both participants, a statement of registration of rights, documents on the ownership of the donor.

The registration period is thirty days. If errors in the compilation are detected when checking, the Rosreestr will suspend the procedure and return the paper to correct them.

Darment Darment Property Share

The contract can be issued on some part of the real estate, while it is necessary to take into account some special conditions.

Before designing a gift transaction, the share must be allocated, and the donor in his hands there are relevant documents for the right of ownership. If the subject of donation is 1/2 share, but it has not yet been highlighted from the general real estate, it is required to obtain the consent of the owners of the second share for the transaction. If the share is less than half, then a conflict can occur with other owners, and then the allocation of the share is in court. It is easiest to give part of the property in privatized property, as it is already indicated as part of the ownership of the donor.

Domestic donation can be issued in two types:

Preliminary - except for property data contains the date of signing an agreement. It is preferable to assure a notary, but not necessarily;

Model - Filled on a standard form, without any refinements.

Under the gift of some part of the property, the same set of documents is needed, the same taxes are paid, it is also necessary to register in Rosreestre in the same time.

We draw conclusions

Both treaties have undeniable advantages and inherent drawbacks. The benefit is tensile, and in this case we are talking about the convenience of the operation and legal consequences for the present and future owners. No matter what about us is a deal, donation or purchase and sale, it remains a bilateral agreement. And what is better for one, then not profitable to another. In any case, it is worth remembering all the above nuances and protect your interests and rights!

Planning the alienation of real estate, citizens are interested, what is better than gift or purchase and sale? Which of civil contracts is optimally issued taking into account risks, winnings and legality. The legislator belongs to the contract and purchase and sale in close by the meaning of civil law agreements, but in private situations there are differences in which one is better to choose to transfer an apartment.

Differences and common between contracts

Before determining that a better gift or purchase agreement, it is necessary to allocate the main differences in the application, type and conditions for the conclusion of these agreements. Dear agreement refers to a free type of transaction, the testament is the same. But the agreement on the purchase and sale is already paid, since it is necessary to pay the recipient of the value of the property. Obtaining a response material or aware good - the main condition.

The fact of relevance of the contract is the main one what is the difference between domestic salesBut not the only one. At the contract of donation, special restrictions on the circle of persons - participants of the transaction are distributed. Basic Group of Companies of the Russian Federation forbids actover by residents by minors and incapacitated citizens. But in terms of donation there is also a restriction for recipients:

employees of educational, medical or pedagogical institutions;
civil servant;
banking workers of the Central Bank of the Russian Federation;
municipal employees.

The prohibition spreads if the donor is in care or treatment from the recipient, or if the gift is performed due to the official position of the recipient. Also, the difference between gift and selling is that the contracts of donation between commercial organizations are prohibited.

In terms of registration, both contracts are issued in writing, if there is a transformation transfer to the share of property or the participation of a minor, since 2016, nootic design has been required. Therefore, that better donation or contract of sale, in terms of the simplicity of the transaction there is no difference. But if the cost of the gift does not exceed 3000 rubles, the agreement may be decorated verbally without writing a written contract. Similarly, buying and sale on the basis of oral agreements, mainly in the retail sale of things.

Is there a fundamental difference in this matter if we are talking about cars, house, land, apartment?

Both types of agreements are subject to state registration, if the subject of the transaction is an object of real estate. Choosing that it is better to make a gift or buying a car, an apartment or a land plot at all, it is necessary to understand that the substitution of one contract by others leads to insignificance of the agreement, as this is regarded as a feigned deal. A context will be recognized as an agreement decorated in order to disguise (hide) a different type of agreement. The negligible transaction leads to a "rollback" of conditions at the time of signing, and may also have additional legal consequences.

Planning to sell an apartment, that is, to make a profit from the transfer of real estate to another person, it is necessary to issue a contract of sale, and if the transfer does not imply benefits, it is necessary to issue a gift.

If it is necessary to make a choice, which is better than the gift or purchase and sale of the apartment, then this is an agreement that reflects the validity of the procedure for transferring property. However, when selling a share in the property, it is necessary to take into account the presence of the preemptive right of interest rates. But, if there is a donation, the co-owners are not the right to prepare. This is the circumstance of what the donation differs from buying and selling, you need to keep in mind before making a deal.

Pros and Cons

The most objectively demonstrates that it is better to give a gift or purchase and sale of an apartment, a detailed analysis of each of the types of agreements.

Pluses of domestic

For donating positive arguments will be:

Ease of design. It is enough to make an agreement and register in the registry. The notarial form is not required if the transaction is carried out between adults and capable entities.
The ability to avoid paying tax. For this it is necessary that the parties appealed close relatives. The difference between the gift from the purchase and sale in the absence of the donor benefit.
The gift will not be considered joint property of spouses, as a result is not subject to section.
A gifted citizen does not bear material and financial obligations Before the donor.
If there are foundations, the gift can be returned ,. For example, if the gifted damage to the property or donor.

Minuses donated

But, despite the considerable list of advantages, with the design of the gift and cons:

The right to cancel the terms of the transaction by the donor performs a minus for the receiving gift, and the complexity of challenging without guilt is a minus for the donor.
The lack of gaining benefits is a minus for the transmitting property as a gift. Although at the same time this fact acts a plus for the receiving a gift.
Recognition of the contract of donation is insignificant if the conditions and requirements for registration are violated. The most common option is a preliminary deal.

For final comparison and choice, what is better to make a gift contract or buy-sell, It is necessary to study the pros and cons of the second option - agreements on the purchase and sale of property.

Pros of sales contract

So, positive factors:

Ease of imprisonment. It is permissible to conclude an agreement in oral and simple writing. In some cases, a notary form will be required.
There are no special limitations in part of the subjects of the transaction. Of course, it is necessary to take into account the limitations of Art. 171 -172 Civil Code of the Russian Federation.
Obtaining profit for the transfer of property is a compensated nature of the transaction. In the absence of payment, the transaction is not recognized completed.
The relative ease of challenge the procedure in case of violation of the terms of the transaction or the rights of third parties.

Cons

Among the negative factors of the conclusion of the contract of sale, there are those:

The need to pay for tax. In some case, this can be avoided, the procedure for providing a tax deduction is also regulated.
A minus for the buyer will need to pay for goods / property in accordance with the requirements of the transaction.
Transition of the acquired property to the joint property of spouses. In the absence of a marriage contract, such property divides equally between spouses.
When selling a share in the composition of the common property, one must notify co-owners, as they have the right to priority purchase (Art. 250 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation).

Cost of registration of contracts

The costs of designing a transaction, subsequent tax payments, commissions and tariffs for the registration of a transaction - these factors determine what is cheaper to issue a gift or buy-selling.

For the Darment Agreement

Based on the terms of the transaction and the proximity of the kinship between the parties, the cost of the transfer of property from one owner to another under the terms of the gift will be formed from:

the cost of drawing up the contract;
fee for registration of an agreement;
NFFL (for the recipient);
fee for registration of the right of ownership, if established by law;
prices for notarization.

Ndfl is paid only by the recipient of the gift and amounts to 13% of the gift value. Recipients in close relationship with donors are exempt from paying. The fee for notary services depends on the price of information and technical work and state duty. The duty is 200 rubles, and the cost of information and technical works is determined by a notary individually. State registration The transition of the right of ownership, for example, the apartment will be 2000 rubles.

For sale and sale contract

The expenses of the sale of sales contract will be formed from such positions:

NDFL (for the seller);
the cost of drawing up the contract;
payment of registration of the transfer of ownership;
price on notary Services.

As can be seen, there are no significant financial differences between the design of these two types of agreements. But on the fact that cheaper to make a gift or buy sale affects the presence of related links between participants. Also in some cases, citizens receive benefits when selling - a tax deduction. And in the absence of the fact of obtaining benefits from the sale of property and to get exemption from paying tax. For example, if the purchase and sale of a car that was owned over 3 years (Article 217 of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation).

Lawyer of the Board of Legal Protection. Specializes in administrative and civil cases, damage to the insurance companies, the protection of consumer rights, as well as cases associated with the illegal demolition of seashells and garages.

Purchase and sale and donation belong to the main types of civil relations on the transfer of ownership. Each of these agreements is issued through the preparation and signing of special documents. Despite similarity, they have a number of significant differences.

Page Content

For most people there is no difference between the concepts of donation or purchase and sale, while they do not have to face them personally. To implement the right choice in favor of the preparation and registration of a particular type of civil relationship, it is necessary to understand what these are juristic documents. What is better in one or another situation, a gift or contract of sale on an apartment - everyone chooses himself. Before you choose your choice on any of the options presented, familiarize yourself with their pros and cons, nuances and features.

Features and risks selling domestic

Domestic call a document that allows one person to become a copyright holder of property, commitments or things of another person at no cost. If the condition is not complicated, the agreement is unparalleled.

The peculiarities of the gift transaction is the specific identification of the object of donation. Under the gift of real estate, the exact area, address, a number in the cadastral register (for land, is put on). The documents necessarily prescribe the characteristics of the participants of the agreement consisting of surnames, names, patientities, addresses of registration and residence.

Other terms of the agreement are included in the text in agreement of the parties. However, they should not be transferred to the legislative standards and provisions. It is forbidden to include in the contents of the contract the conditions requiring the material remuneration from being granted in the case of providing services or the onset of a specific event, the date.

Important! All of the above circumstances are spelled out in some other civil law agreements. The presence of such paragraphs allows you to challenge the legality of the transaction in court.

Make a deal better with the participation of a notary, which will check whether the real estate arrests, tax deposits, mortgages. Apartment purchase agreement or donation agreement for stabilizing civil-legal relations at the legislative level is limited by some factors. It is impossible to deal if:

beloved face under 14 years old or recognized judicial bodies incapable;
property is not the property of the donor;
appraising is the employee of the budget sphere, a legal entity or a commercial organization.

To the risks of sales of an apartment in the domestic include the possibility of challenging its legality, the right of the donor to withdraw the contract in case of cases prescribed by law.

The donator, transmitting the ownership of Obalarm, cannot indicate him how to use and dispose of property. However, if the threat to life and harming the donor real estate on behalf of the presentation is possible, the abolition of the agreement is possible.

Capacity and sanity of the donor can be doubted and examination. The slightest deviation from legal regulatory documents leads to recognition of neglost agreement.

In the agreement, conditions are prescribed, upon the occurrence of which the property rights are transferred, the consequences of unfair use of the gift, various restrictions that prevent full-fledged orders, for example, an apartment.

If the buyer is unfinished, it can refuse to perform data in the oral form of obligations and not pay money for the "product". In this case, the seller has no chance of making money from it by judicial treatment, since the gift implies the transfer of property at no cost.

Features and risks of sale under the sale contract

Under the Sales Agreement, the Document is implied according to which the transfer of ownership of the object of sale from the owner to the buyer for a specific fee. As a real estate, apartments, houses, land plots, shares in houses and apartments, rooms, vehicles, and so on. In most cases, this type of agreements is applied to real estate.

The Agreement is governed by the presence of a number of prescriptions. In the written part of the contract, the data of the Agreement and the subject of the transaction should be clearly defined. Mandatory condition is the writing value of the subject of the agreement. The lack of price entails recognition of the transaction invalid.

Important! The agreement is clearly prescribed not only the rights, duties of the parties to the Agreement, but also the procedure for issuing penalties, for refusing or inappropriate implementation.

The cost of the apartment is indicated by the seller, but it must be within legislative norms. The understatement of the estimated value may cause distrust by state registration authorities and cause reuse of real estate.

It is forbidden to conclude a deal if government agencies There is a ban on carrying out any civil legal operations in relation to this property. The transaction is illegal in the case:

non-compliance with the main terms of the contract;
ignoring the registration of documents in Rosreestre;
evidence of coercion to the purchase (sale) of one of the participants in the process;
lack of resolution of one of the spouses;
if the documents put a signature person who does not have authority to this.

You should not forget about such an important risk as the assignment of the status property bought in marriage. In the case of a divorce, regardless of whose money is purchased apartment, it is divided in half. Interfere the section can only marriage contractcomprising the conditions of the section of jointly proven property.

Sell \u200b\u200ban apartment in the joint ownership of spouses, without the consent of her husband or wife is impossible. Therefore, there is always a risk of canceling the transaction, in case of refusal of co-owner. In case of shares, the right of preferential purchase belongs to co-owners. Transferred real estate to donation, you can amitazing this right.

What is better, it is beneficial to make a gift or buy-selling - depends on many nuances that should be taken into account when choosing a procedure for transferring property rights from one person to another.

What is the gift different from buying and selling

The differences between the contract of donation from the contract of sale of significant. The similarity of the processes is:

transfer of real estate from the copyright holder to a third party;
obligatory registration in the relevant registration services;
contract entry into force after registration in the relevant service;
the existence of property rights of real estate;
the need for written drawing up contracts.

Despite a number of similar characteristics, differences are essential. Darisfactory, unlike buying and selling Add to cart Royalty free. Ndfl When issuing a gift agreement is not charged only with relatives of the first stage, the rest are required to pay a duty of 13%, non-residents - 30%.

Important! The sale of NDFL does not apply if the property is in possession of the seller for more than three years.

During the design of donation, the tax is paid to the goods, sales - seller:

To terminate the contract of donation, the donor is enough to withdraw it, pushing out of legal grounds, and the gifted may simply refuse to adopt the gift.
Purchase and sale is terminated if there are burdens on the property or non-payment of funds by the buyer.

The contract for real estate can be challenged by a donor and other applicants for property law. Equality of participants in the purchase and sale process does not give such an opportunity. The sale of property is not close to relatives makes it possible to get a tax deduction, and the gift is not.

Important! In the process of imprisonment, legal entities do not have the right to participate commercial organizations, representatives of juvenile citizens.

The gift can not get the employee of the budget sector, if he is directly related to his professional activity. The legitimacy of the conclusion of the transaction on the transition of property rights from one person to another for the remuneration is influenced by the capacity of participants in the process. The contract of donation or sale, which is better - is defined individually.

To conclude transactions, participants will need to collect almost the same package of documents:

passports, identification tax numbers in original + copies;
check about the payment of state duty;
application for sample (for domestic);
technical documents characterizing the object of the Agreement;
papers confirming ownership;
the consent of her husband or wife for the conclusion of the transaction;
with shares, the resolution of all owners;
a document confirming the absence of debt for utilities (In the case of real estate).

In the process of registration, some nuances often pop up, the presence of which will require additional provision of references and documents. The number of copies of the contract depends on the number of parties to the contract.

With the existence of the seller of children who have not reached the age of majority, the transaction may be challenged for three years, from the date of its conclusion.

Cost of registration

Sale under the contract of donation will require some costs. They are insignificant compared to the cost of registration of sale and include payment:

NDFL size of 13% of the estimated value of the property, for those who are not in related links.
State duty for registration of property law.
For the help of the notarial office in the compilation, assurance and registration of the contract of donation.

When making a purchase and sale transaction, expenses are divided between both parties to the process participants. For pre-sale preparation of documentation pays the party to the seller.

The buyer will have to pay notarial services, the cost of information required to conclude a transaction and tax (at the cost of housing over a million rubles). In addition to paying real estate cost, it becomes the copyright holder property deduction, in the absence of interdependent relationships between the parties to the transaction.

How best to make a deal between relatives

Many, facing housing problems, wonder how it is better to arrange an apartment between close relatives. A distinctive feature of the contract for the transfer of property for use on the rights of donation is the lack of remuneration of the donor from the gifted.

In case of violation this conditionThe gift can be challenged or cancel. Positive side such an agreement for related links of the first stage and spouses is becoming no need for paying tax rate The size of 13%, paid upon receipt of real estate as a gift from third parties.

Regardless of the number of years, during which the donor enjoyed presented property, the tax on income of individuals is not charged. In order for the transaction to be eligible, it is enough to provide documentary confirmation of related links.

What is more profitable to arrange, gift or buy-sell, everyone chooses for himself. However, give preference better documents, reliable from the point of view of the design of property law. If a donor does not want that in the future, the property fighters the section, it is better to arrange a gift.

Draw up a property purchase agreement better persons With the non-degree of kinship. The document will allow you to take into account the main terms of the contract: the cost of housing, the obligations of the parties to the agreement contributing to the return of funds in the event of cancellation of the contract.

Differences of the contract of donation with purchase and sale is the possibility of challenging. Despite the need to pay NDFL, the donation is more profitable for individuals who trust their relatives. Choosing between the donation contract and purchase and purchase, everyone should take into account the degree of kinship. In the contract of sale and purchase can specifically register the rights and obligations of the parties.